Countertop ice makers have quietly split into two machines that happen to share the same shelf. On one side are the nugget-ice machines that turn ordinary drinking water into the soft, chewable pebble ice that drinks bars, hospital fans and sonic-drive-thru devotees have obsessed over for years. On the other are the frozen-treat machines — the Ninja CREAMi line and its new SLUSHi sibling — which have turned the same counter into an ice cream parlour. This guide covers both, because a household shopping the “Ice Makers & Frozen Treats” category usually ends up deciding between them.
We built this list from hands-on testing and published findings at Tom’s Guide, CNET, Consumer Reports, Good Housekeeping, Food & Wine, Wirecutter and TechRadar, cross-checked against manufacturer specifications and current Canadian and US availability. Where an expert source publishes a numerical score for an exact model, we show it under that product with the source named. Short on time? The GE Profile Opal 2.0 with side tank is still the nugget-ice benchmark, the Ninja CREAMi is the frozen-treat buy for ice cream lovers, and the EUHOMY is the best value route to nugget ice.
Disclosure: CookSmartPicks is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this page, we may earn an Amazon commission at no extra cost to you. Prices and availability change often — check the current price on Amazon before you decide.
Our Top Picks at a Glance
- GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker with Side Tank — Best Overall Nugget Ice Maker
- GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra Nugget Ice Maker — Best Premium Nugget Ice Maker
- Ninja SLUSHi Professional Frozen Drink Maker (FS301) — Best Frozen Drink Maker
- Ninja CREAMi Ice Cream Maker (NC301) — Best Ice Cream Maker Overall
- Ninja CREAMi Deluxe 11-in-1 (NC501) — Best CREAMi for Families
- Ninja CREAMi Swirl 13-in-1 (NC701) — Best for Soft Serve (Newest CREAMi)
- EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Handle — Best Value Nugget Ice Maker
- Silonn Chewable Nugget Ice Maker (Slim) — Best Budget High-Output Nugget Maker
- GoveeLife Smart Nugget Ice Maker Pro — Best Smart High-Capacity Nugget Maker
- Ecozy Smart Nugget Ice Maker — Best for Soft-Ice Chewers
1. GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker with Side Tank — Best Overall Nugget Ice Maker
The Opal is the machine that made nugget ice a household obsession: it presses flaked ice into soft, chewable nuggets that crunch without hurting teeth and hold flavour better than hard cubes. It makes up to 38 pounds of ice a day, produces its first batch in about ten minutes, and the side tank keeps it running for days without refills while the melt water recirculates into the next batch. Wi-Fi scheduling through the SmartHQ app means you can wake up to a full bin. It is big and it is not cheap — but for the authentic pebble-ice experience, nothing else on this list is the real thing.
Yay · Pros
- The original, benchmark-quality nugget ice — soft, chewable, bar-grade
- Up to 38 pounds per day with the first batch in about 10 minutes
- Side tank means far fewer refills; melt water recycles into new ice
- Wi-Fi scheduling, voice control and a self-cleaning cycle
Hmm · Cons
- Premium pricing, well above the budget nugget machines
- Large footprint — measure your counter height and depth first
- Owner reports flag auger and gearbox wear around year three; cleaning discipline matters
Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com
2. GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra Nugget Ice Maker — Best Premium Nugget Ice Maker
The Ultra takes the Opal formula and answers its one persistent complaint — maintenance — with a scale-inhibiting water filter and an enhanced cleaning system, while adding an LED touch display. The ice, the output and the app control are the same proven Opal experience: 38 pounds a day, fast first batch, melt recycling, quiet operation for a machine of its class. You pay a premium over the standard Opal with side tank, but for the household that will run a nugget machine every day and wants the longest realistic life out of it, the Ultra’s cleaning system is the honest upgrade.
Yay · Pros
- Scale-inhibiting filter and enhanced cleaning system for longer machine life
- Same benchmark nugget ice and 38-pound daily output as the standard Opal
- LED touch display with Wi-Fi scheduling and voice control
- Quieter operation than most competing nugget machines
Hmm · Cons
- The priciest nugget machine on this list
- Same large footprint — this is a permanent countertop resident
- Filter replacements add an ongoing running cost
Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com
3. Ninja SLUSHi Professional Frozen Drink Maker (FS301) — Best Frozen Drink Maker
The SLUSHi works a small miracle: it freezes your drink itself, with no ice at all, into a proper frozen slush that stays at texture for hours without diluting. Pour in juice, lemonade or a cocktail mix, wait roughly 30 minutes, and the 88-ounce vessel serves up to seven drinks. It became a genuine social-media phenomenon for a reason — it replaces the blender’s watery compromise entirely. Watch the one hard rule: the drink must contain sugar to freeze properly, so diet and zero-sugar drinks will not work, and small single-serve batches are not its strength.
Yay · Pros
- Real frozen drinks with no ice — no dilution, no blender compromise
- 88-ounce vessel serves up to seven drinks at once
- Keeps drinks at serving texture for hours once frozen
- Quiet, easy to use and a genuine party centrepiece
Hmm · Cons
- Needs sugar in the drink to freeze — diet drinks fail outright
- Minimum batch is several servings; it cannot do one glass well
- Large and single-purpose; it earns its counter space only if you use it often
Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com
4. Ninja CREAMi Ice Cream Maker (NC301) — Best Ice Cream Maker Overall
The original CREAMi became a viral hit because it solves the two problems that make home ice cream makers frustrating: it is fast (under five minutes once the base is frozen) and it turns almost any base — full-fat, protein shake, low-sugar, dairy-free — into genuinely smooth scoopable ice cream. Seven programs cover ice cream, sorbet, lite ice cream, gelato, smoothie bowls and milkshakes, and the two included pints mean a second flavour is always ready. The catch is the 24-hour freeze before the magic, and the machine is loud while it works — but for the price and the results, nothing else in the category matches it.
Yay · Pros
- Turns almost any frozen base into smooth, scoopable ice cream in minutes
- Seven programs, including lite ice cream for protein and low-sugar recipes
- Two pints included, so two flavours are always ready
- Four-star rating from Tom’s Guide’s hands-on review
Hmm · Cons
- Bases must freeze for 24 hours before processing
- Noticeably loud during the two-minute spin cycle
- Takes real counter or cupboard space for a single-purpose machine
Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com
5. Ninja CREAMi Deluxe 11-in-1 (NC501) — Best CREAMi for Families
The Deluxe is the CREAMi scaled up for a household: 24-ounce XL pints hold half again as much as the original’s, and eleven programs add frozen drinks, slushies, Italian ice, frozen yoghurt and Creamiccinos to the scoopable set. CNET’s review praised the quality of the ice cream itself — “on par with my favourite ice cream parlour” — and scored the machine 8.0 out of 10. The Dual Processing feature even lets you put two different textures into a single pint. For families, bigger groups, or anyone who wants the full frozen-drink menu, this is the CREAMi to buy.
Yay · Pros
- XL 24-ounce pints — 50 percent more per batch than the original
- Eleven programs covering scoopable and drinkable treats
- CNET scored it 8.0/10 and rated its ice cream outstanding
- Dual Processing makes two textures in one pint
Hmm · Cons
- Still needs the 24-hour base freeze
- CNET found the mix-in function pulverises chunks rather than keeping them whole
- Pricey, and the XL pints take more freezer space
Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com
6. Ninja CREAMi Swirl 13-in-1 (NC701) — Best for Soft Serve (Newest CREAMi)
The Swirl is the newest member of the family and the one every soft-serve fan has been waiting for: a dispenser handle extrudes proper soft-serve swirls, cones and all, on top of thirteen programs that include a dedicated CreamiFit mode for high-protein, low-sugar recipes. A drip tray and a removable paddle keep the dispenser clean, and the machine still makes all the scoopable classics. Early hands-on coverage from Tom’s Guide is enthusiastic, but note the Swirl’s youth — its long-term track record is shorter than the Deluxe’s — and it is the tallest and loudest of the three CREAMi machines, so check clearance under your cabinets.
Yay · Pros
- Genuine soft-serve dispensing — cones, swirls and toppings included
- Thirteen programs, the most in the CREAMi line, including CreamiFit
- Drip tray and removable paddle make cleanup straightforward
- Makes every scoopable treat the earlier models do
Hmm · Cons
- Tall and loud — the biggest, noisiest CREAMi yet
- Newest release, so the long-term reliability record is short
- Soft-serve texture needs practice to get right
Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com
7. EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Handle — Best Value Nugget Ice Maker
EUHOMY’s nugget machine is the budget answer to the Opal, and the reason it leads the value tier is that it does not feel like a compromise in the glass: it makes 34 to 35 pounds of nugget ice a day, produces its first nuggets in six to eight minutes, and adds a carry handle, a removable top cover and a self-cleaning cycle. Its ice is soft and chewable in the Opal style, and the footprint is small enough for an RV or a bar cart. The honest caveat is the one that applies to every budget nugget machine — long-term reliability varies more than with the premium brands — but for a first nugget machine at well under the Opal’s cost, this is the sensible buy.
Yay · Pros
- Real nugget ice at a fraction of the Opal’s cost
- First nuggets in six to eight minutes; up to 35 pounds per day
- Carry handle, compact footprint and self-cleaning cycle
- Small enough for an RV, boat or bar cart
Hmm · Cons
- Budget-tier long-term reliability varies; owner reports are mixed past year one
- Small water tank needs frequent refills at heavy use
- No app or Wi-Fi control
Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com
8. Silonn Chewable Nugget Ice Maker (Slim) — Best Budget High-Output Nugget Maker
Silonn’s slim nugget machine stakes its claim with output: a claimed 40 pounds of chewable nugget ice per day from a 3-litre tank, in a narrower body than most rivals, with a self-cleaning function and a simple control panel. It is the budget pick for the household that burns through ice — big families, party hosts, anyone with a drinks fridge that never stays full. Treat the headline number as a best-case figure (every maker’s daily rating is measured under ideal conditions) and expect the usual budget-tier reliability spread, but on paper and in the glass, this is the highest-output cheap route to nugget ice.
Yay · Pros
- Claimed 40 pounds per day — the highest output in the budget tier
- 3-litre water tank and a slim body that fits tight counters
- Self-cleaning function keeps maintenance simple
- Soft, chewable ice in the nugget style
Hmm · Cons
- The 40-pound figure is a manufacturer best-case; real output is lower
- Budget-tier reliability varies over the long term
- Basic controls — no app, no scheduling
Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com
9. GoveeLife Smart Nugget Ice Maker Pro — Best Smart High-Capacity Nugget Maker
GoveeLife entered the nugget category with a spec sheet the established brands should read twice: up to 60 pounds of ice per day, dual water tanks with a large external reservoir, Wi-Fi scheduling and voice control, and an AI Noise Guard system that keeps the machine quieter than its size suggests. The ice is properly chewable nugget ice, and the app lets you schedule production around parties or the workday. GoveeLife is a newer name in ice than GE or Ninja, so its service network is younger — but on capacity and smart features per dollar, nothing on this list matches it.
Yay · Pros
- Up to 60 pounds per day — the largest output on this list
- Dual tanks and a large external reservoir for long unattended runs
- Wi-Fi scheduling, app control and voice commands
- AI Noise Guard keeps operation quieter than expected
Hmm · Cons
- Newer brand in the ice category; support network is younger than GE’s
- App setup is part of the experience — it is not an app-free machine
- The RGB light ring is cosmetic; it adds nothing to the ice
Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com
10. Ecozy Smart Nugget Ice Maker — Best for Soft-Ice Chewers
Ecozy’s nugget machine earns its place on one quality alone: its ice is notably softer and airier than most nugget machines, closer to the flaked texture that soft-ice chewers love, while still holding up in a glass. It produces up to 44 pounds a day, carries a double-layer insulated bin, and adds Wi-Fi control and voice commands at a mid-range price. The trade-off for that softness is speed of melt — soft ice gives up faster in a warm drink — and Ecozy is a smaller brand than GE or Ninja. If you chew your ice and find other nuggets too hard, this is the machine built for you.
Yay · Pros
- Noticeably softer, airier nugget ice — the softest on this list
- Up to 44 pounds per day with a double-layer insulated bin
- Wi-Fi control and voice commands included
- Mid-range pricing with a compact, modern design
Hmm · Cons
- Soft ice melts faster in warm drinks
- Smaller brand with a shorter support track record
- App setup required to unlock the smart features
Check Price on Amazon.ca Check Price on Amazon.com
How to Choose the Right Ice Maker
Pick your ice first: nugget, bullet or clear cube
The ice style decides everything else. Nugget (or pebble) ice is soft, chewable and the choice for soda, cocktails and anyone who eats their ice — but it melts faster than hard cubes. Bullet ice, from the classic cheap countertop machines, is hard and round and fine for a cooler, but it is not the ice this guide is about. Clear-cube machines exist for cocktail purists and cost far more. If you are unsure, nugget is the crowd-pleaser and the category most people actually mean when they say they want an ice maker.
Treat daily output as a ceiling, not a promise
Every maker’s “pounds per day” is measured under ideal conditions — cool room, cold feed water, uninterrupted running. Real output is usually lower, and what matters more day to day is the bin size and how fast the first batch arrives. A machine that makes 40 pounds a day but holds only 3 pounds in the bin still needs you to transfer ice to a freezer before a party. For parties, pair a high-output machine with a freezer bag and a scoop.
Cleaning and descaling are the reliability story
This is the paragraph that saves you money. Nugget machines compress ice with an auger, and mineral scale is their enemy: run the self-cleaning cycle weekly if you use the machine daily, use filtered water where your tap is hard, and descale on the manufacturer’s schedule. Owner roundups consistently tie premature failure — including the Opal’s reported auger and gearbox wear around year three — to neglected cleaning. Budget nugget machines vary more in long-term reliability than premium ones, which is exactly why the cleaning routine matters most on the cheaper buys.
Check space, noise and where the machine will live
Nugget machines are bigger and louder than most buyers expect — the Opal family is a permanent countertop resident, and the CREAMi machines are tall and loud during their spin cycles. Measure height (the Swirl needs clearance under cabinets), depth with the side tank, and ventilation around the vents. For an RV, bar cart or boat, the EUHOMY’s handle and compact body are the practical answer, and remember every countertop machine needs a level surface and a power outlet nearby.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are countertop ice makers worth it versus freezer ice?
If your household goes through a lot of ice, or you specifically want nugget ice, yes — no freezer tray reproduces nugget texture, and a countertop machine produces ice continuously instead of one tray at a time. If you only need a handful of cubes a day, a freezer tray or a fridge dispenser is cheaper and simpler. The machines here earn their space when ice is a daily habit, not an occasional need.
What exactly is nugget ice?
Nugget ice (also called pebble, pellet or Sonic ice) is made by scraping thin flakes of ice off a chilled cylinder and compressing them into small, soft pellets. The result is airy, chewable and quick to chill a drink, and because it is porous it absorbs flavour from the drink around it. It is softer on teeth than hard cubes, which is a big part of why people love it.
Do countertop ice makers keep ice frozen?
No — with the exception of a few high-end models, countertop ice makers are not freezers. The bin is insulated, and on nugget machines the melt water drains back into the reservoir and is recycled into the next batch, so the machine never floods and the ice supply never really stops — but the bin does slowly melt down if the machine is off. For a party, scoop ice into a freezer bag ahead of time.
How often should I clean and descale my ice maker?
For daily use, run the self-cleaning cycle weekly and descale monthly, or on the manufacturer’s schedule if it differs — more often if you have hard water. Use filtered water where possible and wipe the bin between uses. Regular cleaning is the single biggest factor in how long a nugget machine lasts, and neglected machines are the ones that fail early.
Can I use a countertop ice maker in an RV or on a bar cart?
Yes, provided three conditions are met: a stable, level surface (the auger and compressor do not like tilting), enough ventilation around the vents, and a standard power outlet — these machines draw real power while freezing, so check the wattage against your inverter or generator before buying for off-grid use. Compact models with handles, like the EUHOMY, are the practical choice for mobile setups.
Building out the whole counter? Our guide to the best air fryers in Canada & the USA pairs perfectly with a home ice setup for parties and weeknight cooking, and you can browse every pick in our Ice Makers & Frozen Treats category for more comparisons and deals.
Last updated: October 30, 2026



