153 guides · All researched, none sponsoredCanada & USA editions
Coffee & Espresso

Best Toasters in Canada & the USA (2-Slice, 4-Slice & Long-Slot Picks)

Best Toasters in Canada & the USA (2-Slice, 4-Slice & Long-Slot Picks)

A toaster is the appliance nobody researches until the old one starts burning one side and leaving the other pale. Then the choice turns out to matter more than expected: slot width decides whether your sourdough fits, browning consistency decides whether setting four is a promise or a lottery, and the difference between a two-slice and a four-slice box decides how breakfast works for a family of five. We compared the toasters that the major test kitchens keep putting on their benches — and the ones Canadian and American owners keep re-ordering — to build the shortlist below.

The honest headline: even browning is the whole game, and it does not track price neatly. A mid-priced two-slice from Breville out-toasts models at twice its price in published testing, while the cheapest pick here still covers bagel and defrost duties properly. Everything below is split by the two decisions that actually matter — how many slices, and how thick your bread is.

How we chose these toasters

We built this list from the tested roundups that revisit toasters every year — Wirecutter's long-running toaster testing, Trusted Reviews' lab reviews, and the specialist comparisons that track owner ratings across Amazon in both countries — then checked every model's slot dimensions, browning controls and extras against the manufacturers' own specifications. Where testers disagree, we say so. CookSmartPicks does not run its own toaster lab; what we do is reconcile the published evidence and flag the trade-offs the roundups bury.

Three things separated the picks. Browning consistency — even colour across both faces and across back-to-back batches, because a toaster that fades on the second round fails at family breakfast. Slot geometry — width for bagels and thick-cut loaves, length for artisan slices. Useful extras only — a bit-more and lift-and-look controls earn their place; countdown screens and motorised lowering are pleasures, not necessities, and we score them that way.

The lineup at a glance

ToasterBest forWhy it made the cut
Breville 'A Bit More' 2-SliceBest overallThe most consistent browning in Wirecutter's testing, with check-and-add controls that actually help
Cuisinart CPT-122 CompactBest budget 2-sliceEven toast at a low price — a Wirecutter pick for years running
Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal ClassicBest 4-slice valueDual controls and four slots at a family-friendly price
Breville Die-Cast Smart ToasterBest premiumMotorised lift, one-touch controls and the same even browning, dressed up
Dualit NewGenBest buy-it-for-lifeHand-built and repairable — elements and parts replaceable for years of service
Smeg TSF01Best retro designThe 1950s look with modern bagel and defrost functions
Hamilton Beach Extra-Wide SlotBest low-budget wide slotBagel and defrost settings and room for thick slices at the lowest price here

1. Breville 'A Bit More' 2-Slice — Best overall

Breville 'A Bit More' 2-Slice Toaster

The 'A Bit More' earns the top spot the boring way: in Wirecutter's testing it produced the most consistent toast of any model on the bench — golden all over, no pale patches, and it kept that consistency through back-to-back batches where cheaper toasters drift. The two namesake controls are the ones owners actually use. 'A Bit More' adds a short burst without restarting the cycle, and 'Lift & Look' raises the bread mid-cycle so you can judge the colour yourself instead of trusting the dial.

The slots are wider than standard, which matters more than it sounds: thick bagels and hand-cut sourdough fit without forcing, and the crumpet/frozen settings adjust the cycle rather than just extending it. The trade-offs are capacity and price. Two slices is two slices — a family doing rounds will feel it — and this is a mid-priced machine, several times the cost of the budget picks below, for browning quality rather than features.

Yay · Pros

  • Most consistent browning in Wirecutter's testing, batch after batch
  • 'A Bit More' and 'Lift & Look' controls fix the two everyday toaster frustrations
  • Extra-wide slots take bagels and thick artisan slices

Hmm · Cons

  • Two-slice capacity only — the four-slice sibling costs notably more
  • Mid-range price for what is, deliberately, a simple machine
  • Brushed finish shows fingerprints on the front face

Best for: daily toast makers who want it right every time and mostly cook for one or two. Skip if: you regularly toast for four or more people — go straight to the CPT-180 below.

2. Cuisinart CPT-122 Compact — Best budget 2-slice

Cuisinart CPT-122 Compact 2-Slice Toaster

The CPT-122 has been a Wirecutter pick for years for a simple reason: it toasts evenly at a price where most models toast unevenly. The compact body suits small counters and dorm-adjacent kitchens, the shade dial covers the useful range without comedy settings, and bagel, defrost and reheat functions are all present — the full working set, none of it decorative.

What the low price gives up is refinement. The slots are standard width, so very thick artisan slices need a squeeze; the exterior is plastic where the Breville is metal; and heavy daily family use will find its limits sooner. As a first toaster, a second toaster, or the honest answer for a couple who toast twice a week, it remains the value benchmark of the category.

Yay · Pros

  • Even browning at the lowest price of any tested favourite
  • Compact footprint for small counters
  • Bagel, defrost and reheat settings all included

Hmm · Cons

  • Standard-width slots struggle with very thick slices
  • Plastic housing feels its price
  • Not built for heavy multi-batch family sessions

Best for: budget buyers, small kitchens, first flats and anyone who wants proven toast without paying for polish. Skip if: thick-cut sourdough is your daily bread — the wide-slot picks serve you better.

3. Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic — Best 4-slice value

Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster

Four-slice toasters split into two kinds: one wide box that treats all four slices identically, and two two-slice toasters sharing a body. The CPT-180 is the second kind, and it is the right design — dual independent controls mean one side can run dark for rye while the other runs light for white, and each pair has its own bagel and defrost settings. For families with divided loyalties, that is the feature that matters.

The metal body is a step up from the CPT-122, the price stays in value territory, and Wirecutter has kept the four-slice version of this design on its list for years. It is not small — four slots of counter is a real commitment in a tight kitchen — and the browning, while good, sits a notch below the Breville pair. For most families it is the sensible end of the search.

Yay · Pros

  • Dual controls — two shades at once, no breakfast arguments
  • Metal body at a value price
  • Full bagel/defrost/reheat set on both sides

Hmm · Cons

  • Large counter footprint
  • Browning consistency a step below the Breville picks
  • Overkill for one- or two-person homes

Best for: families of three-plus and mixed-shade households. Skip if: counter space is scarce — a two-slice plus patience is cheaper in every currency.

4. Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster — Best premium

Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster

The Die-Cast Smart Toaster is what happens when the 'A Bit More' formula gets a premium budget: a motorised carriage that lowers and raises the bread at a button press, one-touch controls with an LED progress ring, and the same even-browning element design that made its sibling the consistency leader. It feels like an appliance from a decade ahead of the lever-and-spring crowd.

Whether that is worth roughly double the 'A Bit More' depends on how much you value the ritual. The toast itself is not dramatically better — the browning gap between the two Brevilles is small — so the premium buys the experience and the die-cast build, not a different breakfast. Buy it as the design piece it is, with open eyes.

Yay · Pros

  • Motorised one-touch lift with progress display
  • Even, consistent browning in the Breville pattern
  • Die-cast body is the best-built here

Hmm · Cons

  • Roughly double the 'A Bit More' for similar toast
  • More electronics to age in a hot, crumb-filled box
  • Two-slice only in this form

Best for: buyers who want the premium countertop experience and toast daily. Skip if: you judge a toaster purely by the toast — the 'A Bit More' is your machine.

5. Dualit NewGen — Best buy-it-for-life

Dualit NewGen Toaster

Dualit builds toasters the way commercial equipment is built: assembled by hand, with elements, timers and parts that can be replaced individually instead of sending the whole machine to landfill when one component tires. The NewGen's browning is excellent — testers consistently rate it at the top for evenness — and the mechanical timer and chunky controls have a decades-long service story behind them.

The costs are literal and practical. This is among the most expensive toasters sold for home use, the manual controls ask for a little attention rather than offering set-and-forget presets, and Canadian availability is thinner than in the US — expect to order it rather than find it on a shelf. For the buyer who keeps appliances for twenty years, none of that outweighs a toaster that can be repaired instead of replaced.

Yay · Pros

  • Repairable by design — replaceable elements and parts
  • Top-tier even browning in tester after tester
  • Commercial-grade build, hand-assembled

Hmm · Cons

  • Premium price, among the highest here
  • Manual timer — no bagel-button convenience set
  • Thinner retail availability in Canada

Best for: buy-once shoppers who keep appliances for decades. Skip if: the budget matters more than the lifespan, or you want one-touch presets.

6. Smeg TSF01 — Best retro design

Smeg TSF01 2-Slice Retro Toaster

The Smeg TSF01 is bought with the eyes first — the rounded 1950s body and colour range are the point — but it is a competent toaster underneath the styling, with bagel, defrost and reheat functions, six browning levels and a self-centring rack that handles thick and thin slices gracefully. Testers place its browning a half-step behind the Breville pair, which is the honest price of the look.

If your kitchen is on display and the toaster lives on the counter permanently, that trade is rational — an appliance you see all day should please you. If the toaster lives in a cupboard, the same money buys better browning elsewhere in this list.

Yay · Pros

  • The design benchmark — colours and finish nothing else matches
  • Full function set: bagel, defrost, reheat, six shades
  • Self-centring racks handle mixed slice thicknesses

Hmm · Cons

  • You pay a real premium for the styling
  • Browning a half-step behind the Breville picks
  • Gloss finish shows crumbs and splashes

Best for: design-led kitchens where the toaster is permanent counter furniture. Skip if: it will live in a cupboard — buy browning, not looks.

7. Hamilton Beach Extra-Wide Slot — Best low-budget wide slot

Hamilton Beach Extra-Wide Slot 2-Slice Toaster

The cheapest toaster here still gets the fundamentals right: extra-wide slots that swallow bagels and thick slices, bagel and defrost settings, and a high-lift lever so small items come out without fingertip archaeology. Browning is serviceable rather than stellar — expect the occasional uneven round at the extremes of the dial — but at this price the comparison is against other budget boxes, and against those it wins on slot size alone.

It is the right answer for a first kitchen, a cottage, an office kitchenette, or as the second toaster a big family keeps for overflow. Daily artisan-bread households will outgrow it; everyone else may never need more.

Yay · Pros

  • Extra-wide slots at the lowest price in this guide
  • Bagel and defrost settings included
  • High-lift lever for small slices and waffles

Hmm · Cons

  • Browning can wander at the lightest and darkest settings
  • Lightweight build — it can scoot on the counter when levered
  • No reheat or check-without-cancelling control

Best for: tight budgets, first kitchens, cottages and overflow duty. Skip if: you toast artisan loaves daily and care about perfect evenness.

Slots, shades and settings: what actually matters

Two slices or four? Count your worst morning, not your average one. Households of three or more who eat together should buy four slots with dual controls; everyone else is better served by a good two-slice and the counter space back.

Slot width beats slot count for bread lovers. A standard slot is about 28 mm; bagels and hand-cut loaves want 35 mm or more, and long-slot models exist for full artisan slices. If your bread comes from a bakery rather than a bag, measure before you buy — this is the single most common reason toasters get returned.

Settings that earn their keep: bagel (toasts the cut side harder), defrost (adds a thaw phase instead of burning the outside), and a mid-cycle check — whether that is Breville's Lift & Look or simply a cancel button you are willing to use. Countdown timers, keep-warm modes and motorised lifts are pleasures. Price them as such.

Toaster questions, answered

Why does my toaster brown one side more than the other? Usually age and crumbs: elements foul unevenly and crumb trays pack with debris that reflects heat. A thorough clean fixes more toasters than any dial trick. If a new toaster does it from day one, that is the model, not you — the consistency picks above exist precisely because this varies.

Is a toaster oven better than a pop-up toaster? For toast alone, no — pop-ups are faster and more even. A toaster oven earns its counter space when it also melts, bakes and reheats. Our air fryer toaster oven guide covers that hybrid choice.

How long should a toaster last? Budget models commonly serve three to five years of daily use; mid-range five to eight. The Dualit is the exception by design — its elements and parts are replaceable, which is why it anchors the buy-it-for-life slot.

What does the bagel setting actually do? It toasts the cut side more strongly while warming the crust side gently — on good models by running the outer elements lower. On the cheapest models it is sometimes just a longer timer; the picks here implement it properly.

The short version

Buy the Breville 'A Bit More' if you toast for one or two and want the most consistent browning in the class. Buy the Cuisinart CPT-180 if breakfast is a family production. Buy the CPT-122 or the Hamilton Beach if the budget leads, the Dualit NewGen if the decade leads, and the Smeg if the kitchen's look leads. Everything else is slot width: measure your bread first.

Last updated: November 16, 2026. We refresh this guide each season and whenever a pick is replaced by a better one.

More Kitchen Gadgets & Knives guides

All in this category →
Best Yogurt Makers in Canada & the USA (And When an Instant Pot Is Enough)

Best Yogurt Makers in Canada & the USA (And When an Instant Pot Is Enough)

The best yogurt makers for Canada and the USA — Euro Cuisine, Dash and Cuisinart compared honestly against…

Kitchen Gadgets & Knives · Updated 16 November 2026
Best Under-Sink Water Filters in Canada & the USA (RO & Non-RO)

Best Under-Sink Water Filters in Canada & the USA (RO & Non-RO)

Under-sink water filters for Canada and the USA — Cloud RO, Waterdrop, iSpring, APEC and Clearly Filtered on…

Kitchen Gadgets & Knives · Updated 16 November 2026
Best Popcorn Makers in Canada & the USA (Every Method Compared)

Best Popcorn Makers in Canada & the USA (Every Method Compared)

The best popcorn makers for Canada and the USA — Dash, Presto, Whirley Pop, Ecolution and West Bend compared…

Kitchen Gadgets & Knives · Updated 16 November 2026

Why trust CookSmartPicks?

How we research

Every pick is compared across specs, verified owner reviews and independent expert sources before it earns a place here.

Editorial policy

Brands can’t pay for placement, rankings or reviews. Ever. Our order is decided by the research, not by advertisers.

Honest by design

We don’t fake hands-on testing. When a pick comes from research rather than our own countertop, we say so plainly.